Art of Gutter Blog

Are Gutter Guards a Waste of Money? Debunking the Myth!

by Julia Watc on Sep 17, 2023

Are Gutter Guards a Waste of Money? Debunking the Myth!

Are Gutter Guards a Waste of Money? Debunking the Myth!

Are gutter guards a waste of money? Homeowners have been wondering about this for quite some time. Gutter guards the supposedly miraculous devices to keep leaves, vermin, and dirt out of your gutters. They have created a heated controversy between homeowners and those who work in-house.

What if you didn't have to worry about your gutters turning into raging rivers every time it rained? You wouldn't have to climb ladders to clear out your gutters anymore. Do gutter guards provide all the advantages they advertise?

In any case, come with us as we debunk the misconception and investigate the reality of gutter guards, whether or not you already believe in their efficacy. Get rid of your gutters and enjoy a cleaner and more efficient house. Okay, so let's begin!

The Purpose of Gutter Guards: 

The gutter guards in our houses serve as unsung heroes, preventing clogs in our gutters and protecting our homes from water damage. Consider them the courageous guardians of your gutters.

Clog Prevention 

Mainly, they block off your gutters from things like leaves, twigs, and even balls. These irritants would rapidly amass in the absence of gutter guards, causing the latter to become obstructed. If your gutters are clogged, water will back up and seep through the foundation and walls of your house, causing expensive damage.

Preventing Water Damage: 

Protect your home from flooding by installing gutter guards. Gutter guards direct water from rain or melting snow away from your home's most susceptible places as it travels down your gutters and into your drains. Wet walls, rotting siding, and expensive repairs are a thing of the past.

The Case for Gutter Guards: 

It's natural to question the value of certain home upkeep expenditures. Gutter guards are no different, but let's argue that they're among the best purchases you can make for your house.

1. Are Gutter Guards Worth the Money?

Yes, they are, and here's why:

  • Preventing Blockages:
  • The best protection against falling debris is a gutter guard. They free your gutters from clogging material like leaves, sticks, and more. There will be less need to clean and maintain the system, saving time and money. You'll no longer have to risk your life by using a bucket to remove debris from your gutters.

  • Extend the Life of Gutters:
  • Guards installed in gutters prevent water from collecting and causing rust and corrosion. As a result, you'll save money on gutter replacements since they'll last longer.

  • Defending Your House: 
  • Protecting your home's structure, siding, and landscaping against water damage is a top priority; gutter guards play a crucial role. They save you money on water damage restoration by diverting water away from your home's weak points. A safe and undamaged dwelling is a great asset.

  • Reduced Upkeep: 
  • Installing gutter guards can help decrease the frequency of cleaning gutters. You'll save money in the long run by not having to pay for cleaning services or new tools constantly.

    Are Gutter Guards Worth the Cost?

    Let's talk about the preliminary expenditure now. There is an expense involved with installing gutter guards. This initial outlay, however, may provide substantial cost savings in the long run.

  • Save Money on Repairs: 
  • Gutter guards, as was already said, cut down on maintenance. Savings on cleaning supplies or labor might add to a significant sum over time.

  • Avoiding Pricey Maintenance: 
  • Without gutter guards, water seepage may cause costly structural issues that need the replacement of the foundation or siding. Protect yourself from these costly repairs in the future by installing gutter guards.

  • Rising Property Value: 
  • Protecting your home's gutters might increase its worth. Homes with fewer potential problems and upkeep needs tend to sell faster. When it comes time to sell your home, installing gutter guards may help you get more money from the transaction.

    Are Gutter Guards a Waste of Money Reddit: Debunking Common Myths!

    Homeowners have debated whether to invest in gutter guards for quite some time. Let's look at the myths about these essential home protections and figure out what's true and what's not.

    Myth 1: Gutter Guards Are a Waste of Money!


    Installing gutter guards is not a frivolous purchase but rather an investment in the safety of your house.

    Evidence and Reasoning:

  • Preventing Costly Repairs: 
  • Gutter guards are equipment that prevents debris from clogging up your gutters. The cost to repair water damage caused by clogged drains may be exorbitant. By protecting your house with gutter guards, you may avoid more expensive repairs down the road.

  • Savings in Effort and Time: 
  • Without gutter protection, regular gutter cleaning is required, either by you or a paid expert. Over time, this ongoing expense might build up. When you install gutter guards, you can save both time and money.

  • Longevity of Gutters: 
  • Protect your gutters from rust and corrosion with gutter guards. This reduces the frequency with which you'll need to replace your gutters. It ends up saving you lots of cash in the long term.

    Myth 2: Solid Gutter Guards Are a Waste of Money!


    If you choose your gutter guards carefully, you won't be wasting your money on cheap plastic ones.


    In contrast to mesh guards, solid gutter guards completely enclose the gutter downspout. They function by directing water flow along a curved surface that keeps out particles. However, contrary to popular belief, solid guards are not necessarily more expensive or less effective than mesh guards.

    Evidence and Reasoning:

  • Effectiveness: 
  • Gutter guards made of solid material are excellent at removing more considerable debris, like leaves and branches. They may still need periodic cleaning, but that is far less often than it would be with uncovered gutters.

  • Sturdiness: 
  • Solid guards are generally more sturdy and long-lasting than their mesh counterparts. They are a superior long-term investment in regions with extreme climates because of their increased resistance to water, snow, and debris.

  • Customization: 
  • Strong gutter guards are available, and some even include heating components to melt ice jams before they do any harm. If you take this precaution, you may avoid spending more on repairs caused by ice.

    Mesh Gutter Guards vs. Solid Gutter Guards: Are Gutter Guards Worth the Cost?

    On the market, two types of gutter guards are primarily available: mesh guards and solid guards. Each has its benefits and drawbacks, so it's essential to grasp the main distinctions between them to choose the most cost-effective option.

    Mesh Gutter Guards:

    Mesh guards have a porous design that enables water to pass through but keeps debris out. Here's why you might want to go with them:

  • Affordable Answer: 
  • Mesh gutter guards are a standard option among homeowners since they are less expensive than their solid counterparts.

  • Effective Filtration of Debris: 
  • By keeping them out, they do an excellent job of preventing blockages and other maintenance issues caused by leaves, twigs, and other significant materials.

  • Versatility: 
  • Mesh guards are adaptable and protect your house from heavy or mild rain in various regions.

    Solid Gutter Guards:

    Solid guards direct water over a curved surface while guarding the entire gutter channel and keeping debris out. When deciding on sturdy guards, consider the following details:

  • Robustness and Longevity: 
  • Generally speaking, solid gutter guards are sturdy and long-lasting, making them an excellent choice for locations prone to high precipitation, snowfall, or debris buildup.

  • More Benefits: 
  • For enhanced safety in the winter, some solid guards include supplementary features like heated components to melt ice jams.

  • Minimized Upkeep: 
  • Solid guards are often less expensive to maintain despite their higher initial cost than mesh guards.

    DIY vs. Professional Installation: Are Gutter Guards Worth the Money?

    There are two primary options for installing gutter guards: doing it yourself or getting a professional. Both choices have advantages; picking one over the other usually depends on preferences, availability, and budget.

    DIY Gutter Guard Installation Costs

    DIY has many benefits, but one of the most obvious is financial. When you put up your gutter guards, you save money on labor costs, which may add up to a significant amount of the total. You may also decide which materials to buy, giving you more leeway to stick to a specific budget.

    If you plan on doing the installation yourself, here are some essential things to keep in mind.

    1. Research: Find out what gutter guards work best for your house and location. Think about the materials, the design, and the longevity.
    2. Tools Appropriate: Before beginning the job, ensure you have a ladder, protective clothing, and quality gloves.
    3. Do As Directed: Please refer to the manufacturer's guidelines to ensure a successful installation. Inefficiency and additional expenses may result from poorly executed buildings.

    Professional Gutter Guard Installation Costs

    There are several benefits to having a professional handle the installation of gutter guards:

    1. Expertise: Only qualified installers can guarantee a perfect fit and optimal performance. They can anticipate problems and respond effectively to them.
    2. Warranty: The cost of hiring a professional installer is worth the peace of mind that any problems will be fixed with no extra expense.
    3. Saves Time: Hiring a professional to do the job will save you time and effort in the long run. If you need more time to get overbooked, this is extremely handy.

    Cost Justification: 

    The advantages over time make the initial investment in a competent installer worthwhile. Proper installation of gutter guards ensures protection against water damage. In addition, with their help, your gutter guards will last longer, reducing maintenance costs and saving you money in the long run.


    Looking at the larger picture will reveal Whether gutter guards are worthwhile. Or are gutter guards a waste of money? Gutter guards protect your house from damage, save money, and make upkeep a breeze. 

    They are a long-term investment in the safety and security of your home. Don't allow your skepticism to stop you from protecting your house with gutter guards, which will last for years.